Beginning this past summer, casting agents for NBC's "The Marriage Ref" scoured the countryside in search of bickering couples ("No problem is too small!") willing to submit to an arbiter advised by a panel of stars, including Alec Baldwin, who, though divorced, did play the title role in a movie called "The Marrying Man." Meanwhile, a National Marriage Boycott is on: its members pledge not to get married, no matter how many people ask them.
Marriage in America is in disarray.
Americans, among the marryingest people in the world, are also the divorcingest. Even during the downturn, business is up at eHarmony, which has taken credit for one out of every fifty weddings in the United States.
"The State of Our Unions," a annual report issued jointly by the National Marriage Project and the Institute for American Values, warns of a "mancession": in a lousy economy, more men than usual are working fewer hours than their wives, making for unhappier husbands and angrier rows. A spike in the divorce rate is anticipated, although this may be mitigated by the fact that divorce isn't cheap and people are broke.
You may think that the mancession would also foretell a falloff in couples counselling, which isn't cheap, either, but there's no sign of a "therapycession." Up to eighty percent of therapists practice couples therapy. Today, something like forty percent of would-be husbands and wives receive premarital counselling, often pastoral, and millions of married couple seek therapy. Doubtless, many receive a great deal of help, expert and caring. Nevertheless, a 1995 Consumer Reports survey ranked marriage counsellors last, among providers of mental health services, in achieving results.
As Rebecca L. Davis observes in an astute, engaging and disturbing history, "More Perfect Unions: The American Search for Marital Bliss" (Harvard; $29.95), the rise of couples counseling has both coincided with and contributed to a larger shift in American life: heightened expectations for marriage as a means of self-expression and personal fulfillment. That would seem to make for an endlessly exploitable clientele, especially given that there's not much profit in pointing out that some things just don't get any better. Not everything admits of improvement.
Rebecca L. Davis: More Perfect Unions: The American Search for Marital Bliss




Subscribe to this blog


